I Thought I Told You To Shut Up!! from Charlie Tyrell on Vimeo.

Reid Fleming and David Boswell are two of the great legendary figures of the 80s black and white comics boom – Canadian born cartoonist Boswell created an enduring character in the irascible delivery man Reid Fleming whose bellicose shouts — “I thought I told you to shut up!” — and hostile approach to dairy deposits made him an angry everyman hero. The character became incredibly popular during its ’80s run, and a big studio movie was contemplated, with Boswell writing the script, until the project reached a film exec who didn’t get the unique, absurd humor of the comic. The rest, as they say, is a cartoonist’s life.

Filmmaker Charlie Tyrell has made a 12 minute short about Boswell and his time in Hollywood, called I Thought I Told You To Shut Up, which I encourage you to watch. The biggest reason: it’s gorgeous. Tyrell has shot even the messiest comics studio to look like it exists in some kind of late autumn haze, and it’s fun looking at all the various environments of the interview subjects. And very clever animation is used to bring even prosaic artifacts to life… all in all a very accomplished piece. (Here’s a short interview with Tyrell.)

If that doesn’t entice you, the film is narrated by director Jonathan Demme (Silence of the Lambs) and features interviews with Matt Groening, Jeph Loeb, Dave (SCTV) Thomas, Ed Asner, Kevin Pollak and Ron (Last Gasp) Turner. It’s very entertaining. And some lessons are revealed.

First off, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles not withstanding, it’s hard to believe now just how popular a black and white comic could become in the 80s. Oddball books like Reid Fleming sold in numbers that DC and Marvel would slay for today and the of the day was all over these comics.

Second, despite that, no one believed it was anything more than an outsider medium and any attention was cause for a celebratory bonfire. When Hollywood came calling, Boswell did the unthinkable and sold the rights to Fleming to a studio outright for a big payday…meaning it would sit in Warner Bros limbo for the rest of eternity. Some other folks have done this, gong for the big cash grab of selling outright instead of the small stipend of an option, but the former is really a fool’s game. Not too many people make that mistake anymore, but it’s still a cautionary tale.

Third off, I know this is a filmmaker by a…filmmaker, but Reid Flemeing still exists as comics, and we are free to enjoy those as we see fit, one would hope. Boswell has a copious website, where I’m sure you’ll go right after you watch the movie. Sadly, ‘m not sure how much of the Fleming oeuvre is in print and available. IDW printed a Reid Fleming: Worlds Toughest Milkman, Vol. 1 collection back in 2011 but I see it is sold out at Amazon now, doubtless due to this film— which has been shown at dozen of film festivals—being released on the internets. IDW’s backlist is something of an Aladdins cave, so hopefully there are more in the warehouse. This is a volume which belongs in ANY library of comics.

If you can’t get it however, there is a Kindle edition of the first issue of Reid Fleming available for a mere $2.99. Just do it! The other issues are also becoming available for Kindle so if you can’t stop after just one, no worries.

Fourth off…talk about old timey comics, Boswell’s inky line and crosshatching technique is a think of beauty that you could only dream of seeing any one learn these days.

If you don’t have 12 minutes to watch the movie I BEG OF YOU, just watch this 8-bit animated sequence that illustrates the difference between selling and optioning a property. This should be shown at every comics school across the nation on business day.

I Thought I Told You To Shut Up!! 8-Bit Sequence from Charlie Tyrell on Vimeo.

Oh and one more thing: this short seems to be set on an alternate world where women died, and exist only as a 2-second flickering archival clip. I know the short is only 12 minutes long and I loved it so much I hesitate to bring this up but…well, that’s kind of an 80s comics mindset as well, so maybe it’s a little too historically accurate. Rather than end of a quizzical note, here’s more Reid Fleming art. And note that Walking Dead commission … Skybound/Wizard World are you listening? Make a Walking Dead/Reid Fleming variant cover a real thing!




  1. Thanks for the kind words, Heidi! But I must correct a misconception: I did NOT sell the film rights, especially NOT for a “big pay day”. I sold an OPTION, for a relatively small sum, and discovered, some years later, that “things happened”, of which I was unaware until too late. By no means a black and white story, but what the hey — at least the character is realized in the comic books. (BTW, Reid #10 is fast approaching completion. Retakes are murder!)

  2. I loved this mini-doc. I’ve still got all my original Reid Fleming books *and* the IDW collection. Unique doesn’t even begin to explain the qualities of this strip. But I’ve got to wonder about Boswell’s other 80’s one-shot book, Heartbreak Comics. It’s just as good! Some of the characters crossed over from Reid’s cast, but there were some new characters as well. Maybe a movie could be made of that property. Hmmmmmmmm.

  3. Regarding the first Reid page reproduced above: that is the first (unpublished) version of page one of #1. It was considerably improved in the published version. So cut me some slack, eh?

  4. Regarding Heart Break Comics as a film: in 1985 I was approached by a producer named Nat Cohen, who wanted to make it with Peter O’Toole as Laszlo! Never happened. Mr. O’Toole is no longer with us, but WB owns the film rights to Heart Break, and wouldn’t Christopher Walken be terrific?

  5.   红旗压瓦机厂,压瓦机,角驰压型机,三层压瓦机,产品中心7,复合板机,天沟地槽机,止水钢板机,泡沫切割机,欧式琉璃瓦,广告扣扳机,楼承板机,彩钢瓦生

Comments are closed.