Since Amazon subsumed the comiXology website this past week, the internet has exploded with reactions to the new digital storefront, with an overwhelming majority of people agreeing that the changes were poorly implemented. The Beat‘s Dean Simons and I composed our own thoughts about the ‘team-up’ last week prior to the changes, but now that everything has live the public has had a chance to share their own reactions to the new “comics shopping experience,” and people are not happy.
Here’s a sampling of the reactions from comics pros and fellow journalists:
— Nicholas Finch (@ObnoxiousFinch) February 18, 2022
In addition to everything else, the comixology downgrade is going to mean nobody gets credited apart from an “author” now. Colourists, inkers, letterers, all excised from the online shop
— Steve Morris (@stevewmorris) February 17, 2022
Every old Comixology link ever used in an article or recommendation piece to take folks directly to that book is now seemingly dead.
Imagining the effort it'd take to go back and now update all those dead-links with new ones after arduous attempts of finding each book on-site.
— Ritesh (@riteshwriter) February 18, 2022
this whole Comixology thing is a real mess and was *entirely* preventable. All they had to do was nothing… pic.twitter.com/cmR8MgsIZ7
— Zac Thompson (@ZacBeThompson) February 17, 2022
Amazon to Comixology pic.twitter.com/o2J7vCwUDr
— Andrea Ayres (@missafayres) February 16, 2022
Love this extremely new broken comixology thing where when I put the full title of the comic I worked on for Comixology Originals into the search bar, and it doesn't even exist anymore.
— sally cantirino (@sally_cantirino) February 18, 2022
Man.. Comixology users losing hundreds of comics that THEY BOUGHT over a stupid Amazon merger just breaks my heart.
— Nikola Čižmešija (@NikolaCizmesija) February 18, 2022
As if the comics industry doesn't shoot itself in the foot enough, @comiXology has to go and howitzer a leg off.
— Evan Dorkin (@evandorkin) February 19, 2022
Hey @comiXology, whoever told you the new app was an improved user experience over what you had before was an absolute liar.
— Bitter Script Reader (@BittrScrptReadr) February 15, 2022
I have spent a small fortune on @comixology. The changes sound really poorly considered at best.
They sent n email today that updates will be forthcoming. I hope so, this is not at all what I purchased.
— Gail Simone (@GailSimone) February 18, 2022
All the noise about JLA/Avengers this week is the single best possible
thing that could have happened to Comixology. pic.twitter.com/dy1hPwMaqZ
— Mark Waid (@MarkWaid) February 19, 2022
Brick & mortar comic shops that would like a signal boost @ me with your store name, location, website and be sure to mention it if you do mail order. Attach a photo if you can. (Then feel free to use that tweet to start a thread abt your shop/employees/specialties/book clubs.)
— Kelly Sue DeConnick (@kellysue) February 18, 2022
Even comedian and well-known comic fan Patton Oswalt weighed in on the changes, giving some much needed love and attention to the smaller publishers who would be affected:
…as much as I enjoy @Marvel & @DC books (and @Image and @DarkHorse) there are dozens of other, smaller companies (like @AfterShockComix, @OniPress, @thevaultcomics, @AhoyComicMags) putting out some of the most innovative, exciting new books…
— Patton Oswalt (@pattonoswalt) February 18, 2022
The whole situation appears to have left comiXology users some combination of angry and confused. Angry that the digital reading experience is poorer now than it’s ever been and that some of the books they spent their hard-earned cash on are no longer available at all. And confused as to why Amazon would make any changes at all when they already had a perfectly good platform in place. What testing went into this ahead of time? Who were the testers? It seems clear it wasn’t anyone actually using Comixology on a regular basis. And most importantly, how will these changes impact digital readership, both new and returning, going forward?
A few days after the changes took place in the app and on the desktop, comiXology CEO David Steinberger sent the following email out to users of the old website:
Hello comics fan,
As you may have seen, I announced our team-up with Amazon and some big changes to your Comixology experience.
I know when apps I love change, that new experience can be a little jarring at first. More updates are coming and we thank you for coming on this journey with us!
We gave the app a complete overhaul, but fear not, the best digital comics reading experience isn’t going anywhere. You can now experience all the improvements we’ve made, such as:
- Faster downloads
- Improved filter, sort, and search, to find your next read faster and easier
- Read comics borrowed through Comixology Unlimited, Kindle Unlimited and Prime programs for free (Amazon Prime members can borrow comics through Prime Reading, a program benefit available to Prime customers)
- Dynamic library cover sizes via pinching & zooming (it’s pretty fun, give it a try)
If you have auto-updates on your phone, your app may have already updated. If you don’t, then go to the app store (iOS, Android, FOS) and update to version 4.0. Keep in mind that if you have a large library it may take some time for all of your books to load into the new library after you upgrade your app.
In addition to the updated app, web and iOS purchasing will take place on Amazon.com. Android and Fire OS customers can continue to shop in-app or on the Amazon store.
- With membership, borrow books from Comixology Unlimited, Kindle Unlimited and Prime Reading
- Price protection guarantee on pre-orders and series subscriptions
- Even better personalized recommendations based on your purchase, browse, and borrow history
The Comixology team is already hard at work making the experience even better. Stay tuned to our social channels as we discuss our upcoming improvements to the app and shopping experience. Please follow Comixology on social media (Twitter, Facebook, or Instagram) and feel free to reach out to our amazing customer service team or reach out to us on Twitter if you need a hand.
Interested in learning more? Visit our FAQ page for more details.
(Ed. Note: Was anyone clamoring for “Dynamic library cover sizes”? Must’ve missed that Twitter discourse. -JG)
While I don’t think this addresses any of the issues, I am hoping that Steinberger and the comiXology team really are hard at work trying to build the service back up. Amazon looks to have pulled the rug right out from under them, and it doesn’t appear as though they had as much of a hand in the new store as Amazon might like the public to believe. I’ve noticed that the comiXology support account on Twitter has been sending out conflicting information on how to use their own site, so it doesn’t seem to make any sense to send complaint after complaint to the poor person running the account.
I have seen a good deal of people say “Oh, just go to your local comics shop” or “this is why I only buy physical,” but the fact of the matter is that it can be much harder for some to get out to comics shops or order physical issues online. Whether it be because they are differently abled or the cost of shipping is too much, there are a myriad of reasons why some people use digital over physical. It doesn’t help anyone to act high and mighty about it, so please respect other people’s decisions on how they choose to read comics.
I’m not too hopeful that we’ll see any significant changes to comiXology in the near future (since Amazon doesn’t seem to care all that much about comics, digital or physical), but I do think that we will eventually see some updates and improvements. Whether or not the website will ever reach the functionality of the old site remains to be seen, but we’ll keep you posted here on The Beat.