All-New, All-Different Marvel Rundown: Week Five

9
20

The Marvel Universe has moved on, but it’s left the rest of us behind.

This week the fact that All-New, All-Different Marvel takes place in the wake of the oft-delayed and currently unfinished Secret Wars event is more noticeable than ever. This is the fifth installment of the ongoing series where The Comics Beat looks at each new title in the All-New, All-Different Marvel line and tells you if these titles are worth your hard-earned dollars.


Deadpool #1

Deadpool

Writer: Gerry Duggan Penciller: Mike Hawthorne Inker: Terry Pallot

Colorist: Val Staples Letterer: Joe Sabino

Deadpool is an incredibly polarizing character right now. He’s a relic of another time who has somehow elevated himself to become one of the unsung heroes of the Marvel Universe. The first issue of his new ongoing takes that idea and expands it into the premise for the whole story. I think that this might not have been the best use of the character, with many writers still struggling to find a unique angle to made Wade Wilson interesting outside of his costumed persona. While I think Gerry Duggan and Mike Hawthorne are both talented creators, I’m not sure if this is the right status quo change for Deadpool’s superhero career.

Verdict: Dropped. My once a year obligation to reading a Deadpool #1 has been fulfilled.


Drax #1

drax-1-cover-155269

Writers: CM Punk and Cullen Bunn Artist: Scott Hepburn Colors: Matt Mila

Letters & Production: VC’s Clayton Cowles

Drax #1…is fine. This issue isn’t unlikely to offend anyone, but I don’t necessarily know who this is aimed at, either. Even fans of CM Punk may not find enough nuance to get interested in the adventures of Drax. With all of the different characters from the Guardians of the Galaxy getting solo issues, I’m really not sure why this would be the title I’d recommend to anybody over Star-Lord or Rocket Raccoon.

Verdict: Dropped. Stopping here.


Extraordinary X-Men #1

55940417dcb5c

Writer: Jeff Lemire Artist: Humberto Ramos Inker: Victor Olazaba

Colorist: Edgar Delgado Letterer: VC’s Joe Caramagna

I don’t think any other comic book this week made me more mad, confused or nervous as Extraordinary X-Men #1. The comic book is a really strange new addition to the X-Men franchise for a number of reasons. Not only do we not know what happened to all the main X-Men heroes at the end of Secret Wars, we were supposed to have known and been provided with some sort of ending that would have ushered in this new X-Universe. I feel very strange about Humberto Ramos being the artist on this main X-Men series because his cartoonish pencils are extremely polarizing.

All this made up for a read that left me with a fury of negative emotions, but I’m still so interested in what’s next for the X-Men that I can’t help want to pick up the next few issues. Getting a stronger focus on Colossus and Magik was nice, and the renewed interest in having former second stringers become top tier X-Men is a cool concept. However, I wish Storm’s costume change had been explained. Finally, because of the way that the recent Old Man Logan mini-series concluded, I have no idea why this comic ended the way it did.

Also, I should add that this comic SHOULD be worth another read after Secret Wars proper has ended.

Verdict: Keeping. Just keep swimming…

If you’re looking for all the answers to your continuity problems, search elsewhere. If you are invested in the X-Men as a whole, this series is worth a look. The comic is probably not where new readers should be advised to start, either.


Hercules #1

4880941-0+herc2015001_dc11_lr-0

Writer: Dan Abnett Artist: Luke Ross Colors: GURU FX Letters: Joe Sabino

I was a little sad to find the comic book to be so pedestrian. I liked most of what author Dan Abnett was doing in the book, but this lacked the fun of series like The Incredible Herc from Greg Pak. With more time, this could develop into something interesting, and Abnett has laid down a certain foundation to continue the book. It was annoying to get some of the themes of the title aggressively tossed at the reader via The Dark Knight Returns-esque newscasters, but hopefully they won’t be back for upcoming issues.

Verdict: Cautiously keeping.  This book needs a few more issues to get into the Olympian heroes’ new adventures.


Howard the Duck #1

detail

Writer: Chip Zdarsky Artist: Joe Quinones Inks: Joe Rivera Letters: Travis Lanham

Howard the Duck seems a little unfocused at the moment. Zdarsky and company’s new #1 with the character continued all the ongoing plot threads and barely introduced anything to readers who are just jumping on right now, making this a poor “first issue” read. However, I can’t get enough of the art from Joe Quinones, and think he’s one of the strongest artists at Marvel today. I’m also interested in the Squirrel Girl crossover. Maybe the series will stabilize in a few more issues.

Verdict: Keep going.


Nova #1

Nova_1_Cover

Writer: Sean Ryan Artist: Cory Smith Colors: David Curiel

Full disclosure: I was ready to hate this comic book, but Sean Ryan’s depiction of Sam Alexander has compelled me to keep reading this series. I love that the book has a sentimental value owed to Jeph Loeb’s son Sam, and I love that Marvel has such a young hero. The art direction actually fits better for this series than I first realized.

Verdict: This is a strong first showing — I’m happy to read what’s next.


The Vision #1

4839761-the_vision_1_cover

Writer: Tom King Artist: Gabriel Hernandez Walta Colors: Jordie Bellaire

Letters: VC’s Clayton Cowles

This was…the book of the week. I guarantee this new version of The Vision will keep readers guessing until the last page. In fact, the last page of the comic teases what’s to come in upcoming issues. Tom King’s writing is fueled with a counterculture agenda that gets deep into the mind of The Vision. Just when this series seems like a family soap opera, King turns the series on it’s own head. His stray observations littered throughout the issue created a thought provoking reading experience as well. Of course, this beautiful Mike Del Mundo cover is soaked in irony– it’s a comic that’s meant throw the reader off course and keep them guessing again and again.

Verdict: Strongest of the batch so far.

9 COMMENTS

  1. I’m an old school Marvel guy so my X-Men are Claremont and Byrne’s X-Men, I think the Fantastic Four should be important to the Marvel U, SHIELD works much better as a supporting character prop, and and Steve Rogers being Captain America was the reason Captain America was inspirational to the Marvel U. So basically the last 15 years of Joe Q and Axel Alonso breaking the eggs to make the perfect omelet. I liked some things but realize that was Jack,Stan, Steve, and the rest of the Bullpen created and was continued and by Thomas, Conway, Englehart, Claremont, Buscema, Byrne, Starlin, Perez, and others was essentially being scrapped. The “rules” that existed previously have changed that I truly expect Uncle Ben to be a resurrected to be a supporting cast member some day and have Axel tell CBR “We want to tell the best stories and this opens the door for all possibilities with Peter and May”.
    That said (long windedly), I’ve decided since all the eggs are broken that I can give this new Marvel U a fair chance no matter how much they say it’s not a reboot. I’ve followed this column every week and find it very helpful. So far I’ve decided to pick up Amazing Spider-Man, Iron Man, and Doctor Strange.

    This week I bought Deadpool, Extraordinary X-Men, and Hercules. I’ll pass on Deadpool next time but the author makes me wish I would have tried Nova (not a Sam fan though) instead. I’ll have to see if my LCS still has it.

  2. Shawn Kane – That’s exactly how I feel about Marvel, though I’ve decided to move on to other comics. It’s better to let people who enjoy the books do so, without my constant complaints.

    Mike

  3. shawn kane said: “i can give this new marvel U a fair chance no matter how much they say it’s not a reboot”.
    that’s the thing, it’s not a reboot. just about every character picks up right where they left off right before secret wars started, just eight months later with some alternate reality characters coming to the 616 MU. when the x-men had their “all-new, all-different” (ANAD) moment way back in ’75 (being an old marvel guy like myself, i’m sure you remember), it was a mix of old and new characters put into a new situation for them to deal with, exactly how many of the characters are being situated today. i guess marvel wasn’t lying about their current crop of titles being ANAD, they just meant ANAD the way the x-men were back in the day, not in a reboot type of way.

  4. I’ll right away clutch your rss feed as I can’t to find your e-mail subscription hyperlink
    or e-newsletter service. Do you’ve any? Kindly allow me recognise in order that I may subscribe.
    Thanks.

Comments are closed.