Welcome back to The Beat‘s breakdown of season three of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, Prime Video’s prequel to J.R.R. Tolkien‘s novel, depicting the rise of the Dark Lord Sauron thousands of years before the events of the book and films. Episodes 5-6 of the season released together this week, so join us for a mix of recap and review of each chapter, sharing our thoughts as a Middle-earth devotee on their merits, flaws, and how they engage with Tolkien’s themes and ideas; in other words, spoilers.
“From Valinor” (written by Justin Doble, directed by Stefan Schwartz):
Theo tracks down Galadriel in Greenwood, but expresses remorse for joining Sauron and killing Arondir, persuading her to take off his Ring. The boy suffers withdrawal symptoms while accompanying her to rescue Celeborn from the Barad-dûr, and nearly reclaims the Ring when he sees the satchel she placed it in has been left by the campfire, although it turns out she put it on her necklace. He hears her singing an Elvish lament, that happens to share the melody of Celeborn’s leitmotif, and AURORA‘s end credits song “Morning Shall Come.” Morfydd Clark has a beautiful voice, and it’s great she got to contribute to the soundtrack.
She tells Theo the forest they are camping by was the one she and Celeborn sat near in the First Age, confirming those weren’t any old mallorn trees, but the future site of their realm Lothlórien itself. Given they lived in (the now sunken) Beleriand all the way out west in the First Age, it must’ve been quite the holiday, although given Sauron later tells Celeborn that Mount Doom was the site of countless executions under Morgoth, this was apparently not so unusual in the show’s universe!

Speaking of whom, Sauron interrogates and tortures Celeborn for any of Celebrimbor’s secrets he might’ve learned from the late Maitalle in Gundabad. These scenes, which are a dark delight to watch given the pair’s constant one-upmanship, must be catnip for shippers, beginning with the sight of the Dark Lord telling Celeborn there’s nothing he enjoys more than dominating others, which is very different from the “healing Middle-earth” pitch he gave her husband.
Celeborn is placed under a repurposed printing press Celebrimbor designed, that gradually crushes him under the weight of volcanic blocks from Mount Doom. However, his will proves too strong, and he spits blood at the Dark Lord when he asks him to beg for mercy. Presumably remembering Celeborn is more useful to him alive than dead, Sauron doesn’t respond with violence for once, and instead wipes and licks the blood off his gauntlet. “Now we are one. Now we are joined. Now we can begin,” he says. Wow: Sauron has always been a Dracula-coded figure, but this takes it to a whole other level.
We’ll return to Mordor, but let’s check in with Khazad-dûm, where Thráin now sits on the throne, and has imprisoned Durin, while ordering guards and stone-singers (except Disa) to search for the Dwarven Rings. As his hunt proves fruitless, he forces Disa to comply by threatening to kill her kids. Disa misleads two guards and Lady Freyja (Emily Lloyd-Saini), taking them to Durin’s cell instead of the Rings, granting him the opportunity to escape. However, the seemingly unconscious Freyja manages to overhear him mention the Rings were hidden in his home.
The Dwarven storyline is shaping up to be one of the season’s weakest. Is Thráin still too blinded by his infatuation with Disa to send more guards to accompany her for the Rings? And surely Durin and Disa’s home would’ve been one of the first places to be been checked for them? What makes it more of a shame is Thráin is a genuinely loathsome villain, whose capicity for evil still remains shocking (his own nephew and niece? Truly depraved), so it’s not unengaging either.

In Númenor, Elrond and Gil-galad convince Míriel and Pharazôn to a parley, with Gil-galad absolutely bulldozing Pharazôn in the process, backhandedly building up his ego by inferring he is a weakling if he engages the Faithful, in front of his own men. Isildur does not trust Pharazôn, but Elrond pulls him aside to ostensibly help retrieve his brother’s artifacts, while persuading him to give peace a chance, and further bond over their bereavement. Gil-galad comes to collect Míriel himself, and even uses his Ring to heal her blindness while doing so.
A fearful reaction to this act of “sorcery” causes the talks to go south, spurring Míriel to request a private audience with Pharazôn. Despite the Elves and Isildur’s fears, it goes well, but she looks uncertain when he begins to lay out a “proposal” for lasting peace. Isildur relays the news to his father and brother, and Elendil charges off to intervene, as it’s clarified to Anárion that Míriel has agreed to marry her cousin. Frankly, I can only imagine how casuals will react to this turn, and the way the shoe drops, but it’s commendable the show isn’t shying away from such a gross aspect of Tolkien canon.
Back in Mordor, Sauron assumes Galadriel’s form to trick a delirious Celeborn into revealing Celebrimbor used Finrod’s dagger, ie. “gold and silver from Valinor,” to forge the Elven Rings: it turns out he asked Maitalle to tell him everything about Galadriel. Sauron plants a kiss on Celeborn before revealing the truth, and rubs salt in the wound with the comment, “And I thought it was bliss when Galadriel submitted to my will.”
I howled with laughter at the sheer audacity of the Dark Lord (and the creators), and can only imagine how others will react: I’m certainly very happy for the shippers, and will engage in some schadenfreude when homophobes get upset at the sight of Sauron kissing a male character. Believing he now has the key to forging the One Ring, Sauron imagines Celebrimbor realizing in horror that he will melt down Fëanor’s Valinorean hammer with the fires of Mount Doom. He’s awfully funny for someone so evil, but goodness is Sauron absolutely delusional.
See you next week for episodes 7-8 (the finale), and as always, namárië. I will personally being seeing episode seven in theaters on Monday, so suffice to say, I feel very fortunate to have my ticket booked.











