Welcome back to The Beat‘s breakdown of season three of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, Prime Video’s prequel to J.R.R. Tolkien‘s novel, depicting the rise of the Dark Lord Sauron thousands of years before the events of the book and films. Episodes 5-6 of the season released together this week, so join us for a mix of recap and review of each chapter, sharing our thoughts as a Middle-earth devotee on their merits, flaws, and how they engage with Tolkien’s themes and ideas; in other words, spoilers.

Elros and Elrond at the start of the Second Age
Elros and Elrond at the start of the Second Age

“The Lady of Lórien” (written by J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay, directed by Sanaa Hamri):

Sauron tortures Marnûkh for knowledge of Galadriel’s whereabouts, revealing he knows the location of the Orc’s five children. Marnûkh gives in, stating Galadriel had planned for Landroval to take them to Greenwood (the forest known as Mirkwood in The Hobbit), where Arondir’s kin are based. Sauron thanks Marnûkh by confessing his children are already dead, and that he will enjoy seeing the Orc submit to his will after he makes the Ring. As they depart Gundabad, Theo asks Sauron if they can use necromancy to speak with his mother, but the Dark Lord dismisses him, saying, “Be not a fool, my servant.”

We get another flashback thousands of years prior, to when Elros, Elrond’s twin brother (also played by Robert Aramayo), revealed he had forsaken immortality to become the first King of Númenor. It’s a really poignant moment, where Elrond is already overwhelmed with grief at his brother’s eventual fate. It is also wonderful to watch Aramayo act opposite himself: he does a splendid job distinguishing the two, employing an earthier register for Elros. We’re left to wonder if Elrond ever visited his brother during his reign, as we return to the present, and he and Gil-galad sail into Númenor’s capital Armenelos.

Gandalf confronts Pallando in his throne room in Rhûn. The Blue Wizard proves too cowardly to accept his offer to turn on Sauron, claiming the Secret Fire showed him his death at the hands of a Ring-bearer, and Gandalf being brought before the Dark Lord. Frankly, this is likely a self-fulfilling prophecy, but we’ll see. Pallando only stops short of killing Gandalf after thoroughly brutalizing him, after a gleeful Khamûl (who wouldn’t have looked out of place with some popcorn) reminds him Sauron wants him alive.

Galadriel and Celeborn's first kiss in centuries
Galadriel and Celeborn’s first kiss in centuries

In Greenwood, Galadriel and Celeborn take a moment to catch up, as she tends to his wounded hand. Celeborn shares he was captured after barely surviving an encounter with the dragon Ancalagon, and saw Galadriel at the end of the First Age, when he was moved out of Morgoth’s prisons during the final battle with the first Dark Lord. Galadriel realizes she saw him too, but had dismissed it as a hallucination borne out of grief, admitting she imagines him often, and her obsessive pursuit of Sauron was partly a result of preventing herself from wallowing in something she cannot fix.

We get a sense of why Celeborn, whom we know canonically very little about, is called the Wise in the book: we learn he maintained his sanity by finding joy in the small things, including clinging to hope his wife was alive, and that like Scheherazade, he spun tales (including ones about her) to entertain his captors. He assuages her guilt about inadvertently abandoning him, and even proves to be open-minded about the possibility that she found another husband in his absence.

He is even perceptive enough to notice she is reluctant to tell him about Sauron, thanks to the affection she developed for him as Halbrand. At night, after rekindling their romance, Galadriel has another nightmare about sleeping with the enemy, causing her to fall out of the tree they were hiding in. The Orcs hear the commotion and alert Sauron, who swoops in on his fell beast. Celeborn surrenders himself to prevent them from finding her. The Elf prince is unaware of Sauron’s identity, prompting the Dark Lord to divulge he was present when he was first captured. He proclaims, “She’ll come to you. She’ll come for me.”

Elrond and Isildur's first meeting
Elrond and Isildur’s first meeting

In Númenor, Elrond and Gil-galad get a feeble reception from Pharazôn, being made to wait outside his study, instead of having a royal procession into the throne room arranged for them. In moments of classic passive aggressive racism, Belzagar asks if he can touch Elrond’s face, because of his resemblance to Elros, and dismisses the Elves’ gift of First Age wine “because it won’t pair with what the scullery’s prepared”.

At a similarly awkward dinner, where Gil-galad is quietly unsettled by Pharazôn’s poor dining etiquette (complete with a gratuitous, Denethor-esque close-up of him chowing down), the false king has a terrifying outburst when Elrond reminds him of Míriel’s promise to return to Middle-earth, nor can he hide just how much envy he has for the “blacksmith” Sauron’s claim to being King of Men. However, Pharazôn eventually admits he will help, if the Elves can persuade the Faithful to stop fighting.

Despite this morally murky proposition, Gil-galad is optimistic Elrond can help reunify Númenor, adding it would fulfill his brother’s dream of a shining example to all Men. Despondent, Elrond decides to visit his brother’s shrine for prayer and guidance. There, he has a classically Tolkien chance meeting with Isildur, who’s mourning his sister Eärien. Both of them are clearly struggling with the notion the dead are with us, with Elrond admitting he cannot feel his brother’s soul in the island he founded.

On realizing who he is talking to, Isildur takes Elrond to Míriel, who in a strong contrast to Belzagar, also feels his face, but only because she is blind. It turns out (understandably, if much to Elrond’s confusion) that she believes he’s here to “lead us to battle,” and we cut to the jawdropping reveal that Elendil is marshaling the Faithful against the King’s Men (presumably) outside Armenelos.

We also see Gandalf, waking up to find he’s strapped to the back of an oliphaunt, as Rhûn’s forces march to Mordor. More war indeed: if it wasn’t clear enough, our heroes may be too late to have prevented the spread of conflict to every corner of Middle-earth.

See you soon for the next episode, and as always, namárië.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.