The gold standard for found footage horror is still The Blair Witch Project. Despite not being the first movie of its kind (The Last Broadcast and Ghostwatch came before it), it did become the film that laid out the blueprint for future forays into the subgenre. Markian Tarasiuk’s Hunting Matthew Nichols explicitly follows in its footsteps, to the point of directly referencing it in the story at one point. The result surprises in more ways than one, even if it ends up feeling like an unofficial sequel to the found footage classic.
Borrowing more from contemporary true crime documentaries, the kind that hyperfocus on digitally clean aesthetics and higher production values, Hunting Matthew Nichols follows the sister of the titular missing person, Tara Nichols (Miranda MacDougall), as she leads a 2-man team to try and uncover the mystery behind the disappearance.

Shortly into the investigation, we learn that Matthew Nichols (James Ross) disappeared along with his best friend Jordan Reimer (Issiah Bullbear) in what ended up becoming a very puzzling cold case that involved a little-known urban legend and a potentially cursed book. It’s revealed that the release of The Blair Witch Project in 1999 changed the two boys’ lives and inspired them to pick up a camera and try their hand at making their own horror documentary. Their approach, though, required a more direct interaction with the supernatural, opening them up to darker consequences.
Hunting Matthew Nichols goes through multiple forms of found footage to get its points across. It takes quite heavily to the true crime documentary style in the early goings, featuring interviews with local historians and community figures, only to then shed it little by little for a more handheld feel that brings it back to Blair Witch. It pays off well. The change in quality and structure mirrors the struggles the filmmakers face as the answers they seek become increasingly more elusive.
Actress Miranda MacDougall does a great job of walking the line between rational filmmaker and traumatized sister to make those stylistic shifts more noticeable. For instance, when emotions run high, the shaky handheld cam takes over. When a bit of exposition is needed, things revert to fixed shots. It’s clever. It lets the performances dictate the intensity of each shot.
The urban legend that Matthew and Jordan settle on for their movie is kept well under wraps for most of the film. It does get a very effective animated explainer that lays it all out, emphasizing the creepier aspects of it to show how it managed to become a local myth. Other than that, nothing ever really materializes until the terrifying finale. This is where director Markian gives audiences what they want.

Hunting Matthew Nichols tries your patience a bit. There are several dead ends throughout the story and it can feel repetitive, especially because so little is shown or discussed about the urban legend. In Blair Witch, the legend is felt throughout the entire film, like an invisible force that’s always nearby. There’s a method to the madness the three filmmakers in that movie are subjected to. Things ramp up in violence and fear even when you barely see anything supernatural happen onscreen. A lot of it is excellent sound design and suggestion.
Markian prefers to delay gratification significantly and take it as close as possible to its breaking point. The urban legend in his story suffers a bit because of it, but that all changes the closer we get to the end. This is where all the stops are pulled and pure terror takes over.
It would be criminal to spoil the ending here, but suffice it to say that it reframes the story in a way that makes the repetitiveness and the rollout of its more underdeveloped ideas worth it. Again taking a page from Blair Witch, the final sequence is where myth and reality collide. Answers are provided through a series of expertly choreographed moments that extract a lot of dread and doom from the bits of pieces of the mystery we’ve gotten throughout. Much like its filmic inspiration, Matthew Nichols comes together beautifully in its finale.

Markian’s take on found footage horror might have too much Blair Witch in it, but there’s enough here to set it apart. Success lies in the payoff. It rewards patience with a display of horror that leaves a lasting impression. Ultimately, Hunting Matthew Nichols questions whether some answers are worth searching for, and whether we’re ever truly ready for the things they might bring to light.










