There is arguably no comic book more influential than Action Comics #1, and the folks at Landry Pop Auctions are holding a special auction for any collector looking for this comic-book holy grail. Not only is it the most sought-after comic book up for sale, but this copy is also the highest-graded, with a CGC 9.6 A-5 grade. This copy of Action Comics has been restored to the highest possible level to get as close as we could to grabbing the book off a newsstand in 1938.
 
Landry Pop Auctions founder Travis Landry talked with The Beat about this one-of-one CGC 9.6 A-5 copy of Action Comics #1 going up for auction, the expectations when the auction closes this coming November 17, as well as what it’s like to display such a rare and expensive book at one of the busiest conventions in the world, New York Comic Con.
 
This interview has been edited for clarity and brevity.

Action Comics #1 (DC Comics, 1938).
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

Javier Perez: The auction is called The Last Son of Krypton: The Birth of an American Icon. I know about the CGC 9.6 A-5 Action Comics #1. Are there other items?

Travis Landry: November 17th, it’s a one-lot item. We’re just selling the CGC 9.6 A-5 Action Comics #1. But then the following day, on November 18th, we have 145 really great lots across the block of both comic books and original artwork.

Rob Liefeld X-Force #2 Splash Pages 30 and 31 Original Art (Marvel Comics, 1991)                                                            Pencil and ink on Bristol board. 22¼ h × 17 w in (57 × 43 cm)
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions
Marvel Comics Giant-Size X-Men #1 CGC 9.8 (USA, 1975) Estimate: $12,000–18,000
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

Perez: As far as published pages?

Landry: Yeah, like there’s a great double-page splash of X Force #2, full-size Juggernaut. There’s an original cover to Chamber of Chills, some pre-code Horror. There’s some really strong original artwork for good comic books.

We call it Icons and Heroes. It’s a great selection of books, from the Golden Age through modern, plus some original artwork.

There’s a Detective Comics #168—the first appearance of Red Hood — in a CGC 6.0 blue label, which is really good for that book. Yeah, there’s a lot of great slab selling. There’s an Amazing Fantasy #15 in there, the first appearance of Spider-Man.There’s a Giant-Sized X-Men #1 in a 9.8. With the X-Men coming back in Avengers Doomsday, it’s a very timely book right now.

Just some great original artwork by Rob Liefeld. Al Avison for the pre-code horror on Chamber of Chills #12. If you check out the website landrypop.com and go through the catalog, there’s some really interesting stuff.

Al Avison 1920–1984 Chamber of Chills #12 Original Cover Art (Harvey Publications, 1952)                                              Ink on Bristol board.18⅞ h × 13⅛ w in (48 × 33 cm) Estimate: $10,000–15,000
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

Perez: Can I ask about the CGC 9.6 A-5 Action Comics #1?

Landry: Yeah. So it was offered to us. We competed against other auction houses to be able to handle the book, you know, but ultimately our pitch worked for the client and his broker.That’s where we came up with the one-lot auction concept, which isn’t new to the auction world. It’s definitely how dinosaur fossils have been sold, or how really important pieces of art have been sold. But it’s the first time we’ve taken that concept and applied it to the comic book realm.

It’s my friends over at Stray Flex and Collectibles out of Texas. It is his client who owns the book. And we work together to bring it to market and put this auction on.

DC Comics Absolute Batman Ashcan #nn CGC 9.8 Foil Edition (USA 2024) Estimate: $3,000–5,000
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

Perez: That’s really cool that you guys are accommodating the owner of it, that you guys are working hand in hand

Landry: That’s really our advantage for LPA; we’re not a high-volume auction house.

It’s a more curated approach to our sales. We’re not putting thousands of items in a single auction. Even our biggest auctions rarely have more than 300 pieces; our photography, our website presence, just the whole vibe of the brand. We’re trying to apply that finer touch to the collectibles world, compared to the industry standard.

E.C. Comics Crime SuspenStories #22 CGC 6.0 (USA, 1954) Estimate: $10,000–15,000
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

Perez: How long have you guys been doing it?

Landry: So we officially made two years of LPA back in July. But this is what I’ve done my whole life. I worked where I met my wife, and she worked at another auction house. I was there for over 10 years, and I also work for PBS on Antiques Roadshow. I do all their pop culture items. This will be my 11th season.

Perez: I wanted to ask about the purple label on the book. What kind of restoration work went into it?

Landry: It has had what we would call ‘extensive restoration’. On the CGC label, the letter indicator ABC indicates the level of restoration. A means it’s true professional-grade, museum-quality; B is in between, and C is amateur; and the numeral 5, the end of the spectrum, means extensive, while 1 would be slight.

Basically, the book has been fully restored in terms of pieces, added color, and touch-ups. They’ve done everything they can to make the comic as beautiful as possible, to make it as it would have looked in 1938.

So the analogy that I’ve been giving to everybody is: if you’re into antique cars and there’s a really rare Duesenberg or an Auburn, one of these great pre-war cars, It’s a 1930s car, but everything on the car has been restored. It’s brand new. It was made, and they brought it back to life as it would have been then.

And it’s the same treatment that was done to this CGC 9.6 A-5 Action Comics #1: everything was done to museum-grade, the highest quality, to return this book to its original greatness of how it would have looked on a newsstand in the summer of ‘38.

Justice League of America #117 Cover Original Art (DC Comics, 1975)
Mike Grell. Justice League of America #117 Cover Original Art (DC Comics, 1975)
Ink and pencil on Bristol board. 17¼ h × 1⅜ w in (44 × 3 cm) Estimate: $15,000–20,000
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

Perez: So it’s the finest copy in existence?

Landry: It is. It’s one of one. It is the highest numerically graded Action Comics #1, regardless of label color. The highest blue label is a 9.0. There are three other 9.4 restored copies on the CGC census. I can say it is truly the single-handed, finest copy. It is pretty remarkable for a collector or investor to be able to make that claim.

Marvel Comics Star Wars #1 CGC 9.8
(USA, 1977) Estimate: $2,000–3,000
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

Perez: Where does Action Comics  #1 sit as far as the holy grails that people are trying to collect in the comic book world?

Landry: We wouldn’t have the modern era of superheroes as we know it today if it weren’t for Action Comics #1 in 1938. Comic books existed before Superman; that’s what we call the Platinum Age. The comic books and similar publications at that time were crime-fighting characters, or medical or military stories. So they were all heroes.

Until a guy coming from the planet Krypton who could shoot lasers out of his eyes changed that. That is a totally novel concept that never existed before Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster created Superman, and that’s June 1938, with Action Comics #1. That’s how we identify the start of the Golden Age of comic books. It’s a very sought-after book.

Ryan Ottley Invincible Original Art Illustration pencil and blue pencil on cardstock 12 h × 9 w in (30 × 23 cm)          Estimate: $3,000–5,000
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

Perez: I understand there have been some big auctions recently for older Superman and Action Comics books. Are you guys really enthusiastic about the outcome of this auction?

Landry: Yeah, the bidding is currently at 800,000 plus premium. If it closes now, that buyer is paying 976,000. We don’t know where it’s gonna end. It’s totally uncharted territory because before this book, the highest restored Action Comics #1 at auction was 575,000.

Now, there was a purported sale during New York Comic Con this year that privately sold on the floor at 1.3 million. We don’t know who owns it or what happened with that transaction, even though it’s been reported.

But so right now, you know, we’re already happy with where it is. Obviously, you always want to see something sell for more, but I don’t want to jinx it.

Craig Rousseau and Terry Beatty. Batman Beyond #8 Cover Original Art (DC Comics, 2000)
(USA, 2000) ink and pencil on Bristol board
17 h × 12 w in (43 × 30 cm) Estimate: $2,000–3,000
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

Perez: Speaking of art going on out on the convention floor, I wanted to ask about this CGC 9.6 A-5 Action Comics #1 going to LA and to New York. Can you tell me about that?

Landry: Yeah, the first time we previewed the book was at New York Comic Con. So we were keeping it pretty tight-lipped about having the comic on consignment, and we timed it with our video with the CGC. We unveiled the book publicly the Tuesday before New York Comic Con then the preview went on Thursday, the opening day.

We put the book on display and started it at half a million, and even on that first opening bid, it was going to become the most expensive restored comic to ever sell at auction.

On day one of New York Comic Con, within a few hours of the show opening, it was bid 500,000. Then, by day two, a second or third bid came in; finally, on Monday after New York Comic Con, the bidding reached 800,000. And it’s been stalled there. 72 people have registered to bid on it. There are 30 people beyond being registered actively watching it in their account.

I think because it’s the highest-graded one of one, it’s never been sold publicly before. So people don’t want to show their hand too early, and that’s why we don’t know what’s going to happen at auction. People are going to come in and bid.

Perez: Say somebody was interested in this CGC 9.6 A-5 9.6 Action Comics #1 or maybe some of the stuff that’s going on the day after. Where would they go?

Landry: They would go to landrypop.com; that is our website. You can follow us at Landry Pop Auctions on Instagram, and I’m at Pop Culture Travis on my personal account.

Action Comics #1 auction
Action Comics #1 (DC Comics, 1938).
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions
Action Comics #1 (DC Comics, 1938).
Photo courtesy of Landry Pop Auctions

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.