Home Publishers DC DC ROUND-UP: DARK CRISIS: YOUNG JUSTICE #2 doesn’t pull punches with its...

DC ROUND-UP: DARK CRISIS: YOUNG JUSTICE #2 doesn’t pull punches with its history

9

THIS WEEK: The past of Young Justice gets a second look in Dark Crisis: Young Justice #2. 
Note: the review below contains spoilers.  If you want a quick, spoiler-free buy/pass recommendation on the comics in question, check out the bottom of the article for our final verdicts.


Dark Crisis: Young Justice #2

Writers: Meghan Fitzmartin
Artist: Laura Braga
Colors: Luis Guerrero
Letterer: Pat Brosseau
Cover: Max Dunbar and Luis Guerrero

As a kid, Young Justice should have been my jam. I loved Robin and Superboy, reading both of their solo series every month. I didn’t really know Impulse, but a book that teamed up the other two? Should have been catnip to me. So way back in 1998, I picked up the first issue of Young Justice. I never bought another issue of that series.

That first issue of the series turned me off so much, that it would be years before I tried the series again, loaned to me by a friend who loved it. I read the whole series then, out of obligation to see what my friend loved about it, and not finding anything worthwhile to take away from it.

So what exactly turned me off of Young Justice those first two times? Well, that very first issue was one of the most misogynistic and immature books I’ve ever read, and even as a 14-year-old the sense of humor felt gross and unnecessary. The plot revolved around a mousy woman named Nina Dowd getting superpowers from an Apokolips Space Rock. What powers? Well, the powers of big ol’ boobies of course. You see Peter David had to make a pun with the character’s name, and Nina Dowd became The Mighty Endowed. And she was defeated by… being too top-heavy and falling over. Because that’s what happens with women with large breasts, they just can’t stand up for more than thirty seconds without gravity taking them down.

That first issue would go to set the tone for the entire series. Even when the series added female characters, they were often overlooked and sidelined, frequently used as plot devices for the boys.

Last month, when the first issue of Dark Crisis: Young Justice dropped, Meghan Fitzmartin and Laura Braga surprised me by bringing back the Mighty Endowed, just to absolutely trash the idea of that villain. It delighted me because it took the thing that was the biggest failing of the original series and poked it so full of holes it looked like a pair of crocs.

But that was only the start of how this series would take a fine lens to the failings of the original series. Dark Crisis: Young Justice #2 pulled no punches as it looked at the history of the series. Fitzmartin took Peter David’s writing to the mat, repeatedly in this issue, while signifying how much these characters have grown over the years.

Our heroes find themselves back in their past when things were supposedly simpler and better. But they find themselves a bit uncomfortable here. Impulse notes that “This isn’t even our past. This place… it’s like our past got the design wrong. And going out of its way to be sexist, racist, homophobic… this place is for immature boys. That’s not us.” It’s really examining the dangers of looking at the past through rose-colored glasses and doing a great service by having most (though not Superboy) of the characters realize that this is not the past as they remember it to be. This is the past as seen through Peter David’s eyes and as such it is much more immature and problematic.

A key moment of this was the interaction that Robin had with Batman. As we saw in Batman: Urban Legends #10, the Bruce that Tim knows was supportive and happy for Tim finding his own happiness with Bernard. However, the Bruce of the Peter Davidverse? Less so, going as far as to call Tim’s sexuality a phase, a phrase that absolutely would have felt right at home in David’s era of Young Justice. That confrontation was Robin’s biggest clue that something was wrong, but wouldn’t be the last thing to examine the team’s past in the book.

Back in the main DCU, Cassie Sandsmark is trying to recruit Cissie King to help her find the boys, and Cissie is the one who most deeply cuts through the issues of the original series. She has two bits of dialogue that are particularly scathing. The first, “I only remember fighting people the Justice League didn’t understand. Like women. People from other countries. Folks who were just doing their best.” really cuts to the point that often the villains in David’s stories were marginalized and misunderstood, and in a world with justice and equity, they wouldn’t have necessarily been villains. This even goes back to the Mighty Endowed. She had no reason to be a villain, she had been a run-of-the-mill archeologist, but sudden big boob powers made her evil before making her collapse.

The second cutting line that Cissie delivers is aimed at Cassie, and how she seems to always be defined by the boys of the group. She’s Kon’s girlfriend or she’s Tim’s girlfriend, or she’s just the girl of the group. During David’s run she never really got to have agency of her own, and that only got a little better during Geoff Johns’s Teen Titans. “I stopped being a superhero because of the toxicity. Your life revolves around those three boys, and you like it. You like the mess don’t you? But who are you without them? I didn’t want my life to end up like yours. I didn’t want my decisions to be overshadowed by three privileged idiots. who had the whole world handed to them on a silver platter, while you and I scraped for any attention.”

We’re only two issues into this series, and it’s already thoroughly dissected the history of the book and the characters, and I look forward to seeing how much more insight is delivered in coming issues.

Verdict: BUY 


Round-Up

      • Artemis: Wanted was an absolute banger by Vita Ayala and Skylar Patridge. Patridge’s Artemis is huge and intimidating but still undoubtedly feminine. Ayala weaves a compelling story about secrecy and redemption. The Artemis plotline has been the best part of the Wonder Woman books, and this is no exception.
  • World’s Finest finished its first arc, but left enough hanging to entice us into the next. Namely, where or when is Dick Grayson. When this series started, I didn’t expect Supergirl and Robin to play such a big role, but after months of Tom King’s Supergirl, having Mark Waid writing her was a welcome change of pace and the Dan Mora art was some of the best I’ve ever seen from him.
  • Catwoman #45 continues to be an incredibly engaging story, and it was remarkably fun to see Selina interact with the Batfam in this issue, with all the tensions that are between them.

Miss any of our earlier reviews? Check out our full archive!

9 COMMENTS

  1. Not debating Peter David’s writing but can we please acknowledge that the Mighty Endowed was a parody of the 90s trend of having unreasonably top heavy women on every team?

  2. Assigning the “phase” comment to Peter David (as “something that would have been right at home”) seems really unfair. Peter David didn’t write that line, and nothing in his decades-long body of work suggests he ever would, even in the less enlightened 90’s. The whole point of that scene, stated explicitly by Impulse, is that it’s NOT their real past. It’s an unconvincing cover band version.

    I never really cared much for classic YJ, but it was pretty clear this issue was taking some major liberties with that series to make its point. That’s fine, of course, but it’s not a fair criticism of David’s run.

  3. The person writing this article speaks from the purest possible ignorance.
    We can start with the fact that, as she says herself, she never read Peter David’s highly remarkable original Young Justice (1998), simply that Mighty Endowed was nothing more than a quick joke making fun of the cliche of sexualized female characters in comics, but apparently his 14-year-old child brain did not allow him to distinguish this.
    “The girls were just left out and plot objects for the boys.” Again this person proves to be highly ignorant when it comes to reviewing a comic, which apparently is supposed to be her work on this website.
    Just to clarify her, she is literally judging a series that she never read but she got an idea of how it was enterely from half an issue that she read 24 years ago.
    Very easily it can be argued that the girls in this series used to have the same prominence as everyone, even probably more than the boys (in reality the prominence of the whole team is quite well balanced most of the time), this is largely due to the fact that they did not have their own regular series unlike the boys.
    Arrowette’s story arc ceasing to be a hero due to her realization that she could kill criminals if she lost control, at the same time doing a good critique of America’s burlesque gun control, could easily be the best arc of the entire series. (and by the way here we see that he is being totally ignored by Meghan Fitzmartin with a false story about toxicity).
    “Cassie was a character with no agenda of her own”, God, really it’s just not absolute ignorance, it’s supposed to be the job of the person who wrote this fucking review to know the comics that she has to evaluate.
    I’ll just say, Cassie is the character with the most development throughout the entire series (along with Cissie, whom Fitzmartin must hate to lie about her story and her character itself), for a reason Cassie would have been the team leader during the series. second half of the series and official spokesperson for the team during Sins Of Youth, of course the person who wrote this review will be completely unaware of what the hell I’m rambling on, but well clearly having read half an issue once more than 20 years ago supports what damn she passed as a review.
    By the way, quite remarkable how David handled discrimination and sexism in his run, giving as an example Traya Sutton, daughter of Red Tornado who suffered from this in her school and people’s hatred, fortunately she got ahead with the help of the team and his father.
    Finally, please never tell this enlightened person about Peter David’s run on Supergirl (1996-2003) and from which the CW series takes many elements, since she declares himself a “superfan” of it, she will probably have a seizure or suffer a heart attack if she finds out.
    Peter David’s run in Young Justice was perfect them? No, but is not that far.

  4. So does this Young Justice comic have an artist? Seems like something to have an opinion on in a review. Maybe that got cut to make room for accusing Peter David of doing the homophobia in this comic he didn’t write. Super weird thing to do btw!

    Both this comic and review are taking wild swings at an imaginary past they’ve created. Saying the girls were overlooked and sidelined in Young Justice is flat out lying. Wonder Girl, Arrowette, Empress and Secret got more focus than the boys as the series went on. Cassie’s whole character being reduced to who she was dating was entirely Geoff Johns’ Titans. Cissie’s actual reason for leaving the team is ignored to make it about the boys. This story makes that character less interesting, blames someone else, and then has her, a white woman attending a private school who’s been in the Olympics, call her friends privileged idiots and not care about their wellbeing. You find that insightful?

    Bad comic, embarrassing review.

  5. I have in fact, read the entirety of the series. I said as much in this review that you apparently didn’t read either. “that it would be years before I tried the series again, loaned to me by a friend who loved it. I read the whole series then” – beyond that I also reread the entire series last year as I was reading through all of the 1990s Superman books, to see if maybe, just maybe, it aged better than I expected. It did not. Thanks for reading!

  6. These sorts of articles truly confuse me. Do you (the author) realize that writing what you think women want to hear in a white-knight fashion will not in fact make you attractive to them? Quite the opposite in fact. There is nothing wrong with being a red-blooded, testosterone filled 14 year old male enjoying well endowed (or under-endowed) scantily clad (or fully clad) women in comics. Try owning that and you’ll find women actually respect you. What you need to understand is that being normal is not “probablamatic”, it is perfectly natural and no politically correct “movement” is going to change hundreds of thousands of years of evolution. Comic books are supposed to be escapist entertainment and yes, they can often times tackle deeper issues when handled by expert authors which are few and far between and almost non-existent these days. Pretending that “women empowerment” is drawing and writing women that act like men and making sure that all the men around them are weak and ineffectual (even “Super” men) is not tackling any issue whatsoever, it is merely bad writing from an inferior writer pandering to a very minor minority.

Comments are closed.

Exit mobile version