It’s that time of year! SF retailer Brian Hibbs has released his annual analysis of the Bookscan 2013 sales charts. This chart is subscriber only, so technically this is a leak, so if you want to download your own version of the top selling 750 graphic novels of the year, go here.
Now, as we all know, Bookscan IS NOT 100% of GN sales, even in bookstores. The numbers do not includes comics shop sales, and are billed as 85% of books sold in regular bookstore outlets. While Walmart has been added to the outlets reporting, I’d hazard a guess that those numbers are still low, as they do not include library sales, book clubs and so on.However, as I always say, these numbers do provide a metric. These are the books that sold in the stores that report to Bookscan, and while they should not be taken as final totals, they do provide a glimpse.
Hibbs is quite busy opening a second store so we should all be grateful for him taking the time to do all this. I know veteran chart watchers have probably read the whole thing already but here’s a bit of commentary. The top 20 books and are as follows:
146,483 — TALES FROM A NOT SO FABULOUS LIFE
113,301 — BIG NATE GAME ON
95,593 — WALKING DEAD COMPENDIUM 1
94,329 — STAR WARS JEDI ACADEMY
89,901 — DORK DIARIES OMG ALL ABOUT ME
81,843 — DRAMA
81,559 — BIG NATE GENIUS MODE
75,132 — WALKING DEAD COMPENDIUM V 2 TP
65,935 — BIG NATE I CANT TAKE IT
59,112 — BIG NATE MAKES THE GRADE
44,988 — WALKING DEAD V1 DAYS GONE BYE
43,890 — PERSEPOLIS 1
38,871 — WALKING DEAD V18
33,477 — MAUS I
32,796 — WALKING DEAD VOL 17 TP
30,904 — CHALLENGE OF SAMUKAI
30,336 — SAGA V 1 TP
30,244 — WALKING DEAD V 19
28,631 — NARUTO V 60 EYES THAT SEE IN T
28,512 — ATTACK ON TITAN
The Walking Dead, kids comics, backlist classics and a few manga. Pretty much a typical year. The #1 book, for the third year in a row is the first Dork Diaries book by Rachel Renee Russell. This is a little bit misleading as this is the distaff version of the hybrid Wimpy Kid which isn’t on the list, which sold a bunch more copies, but there ya go. Who says there are no African American women in comics?
I doubt too many industry watchers without children think of Lincoln Pierce’s Big Nate as the equal of Walking Dead in popularity but..it kinda is.
Jeffrey Brown’s Jedi Academy book is likewise a “hybrid” book of charts graphs and narrative, but it is adorable. (I gave it to a young cousin for Christmas and he immediately dived into reading it.) However, I’m thrilled to see the success of Brown and Raina Telgemeier on this chart.
I don’t mean to steal Brian Hibbs’ hard work but I’m going to reprint just ONE chart, which shows overall non-manga GN sales for the past few years decade:
|% Change||Total Pieces||% Change||Total Dollars||% Change||Av. Sale
|Av. $ per title|
Pretty sure that 3,000,000 piece count for 2007 is wrong but other than that this is a nice chart that shows a steady growth and decent sales. The $131,767,547 total for 2013 is not as much as it could be but it isn’t shabby either.
The main takeaway? KIDS LIKE COMICS. We all knew that. DC was the #1 GN publishers in bookstores for the year as they have been for awhile, but they were followed by Image, Scholastic, Penguin Random House, Andrews McMeel, Simon & Shuster, Marvel, Papercutz, Harper Collins and Dark Horse. Marvel is once again an underperformer given their dominance of the periodical market, but we’ve been singing that song for years. If I have time (ha) I’ll do a breakout of the chart by company that will reveal what their bestsellers were.
Hibbs has been doing this column for a decade now but the earliest Bookscan chart from 2003 isn’t online any more. Of course Heidi the Hoarder saved a copy, and as my special 10 year anniversary gift, here it is, unless they make me take it down. It isn’t a perfect comparison because this chart was only the year end totals in the last week of the year, but it’s what we have.
In case you are wondering, here are the top 20 books from 2003.
1. GET FUZZY EXPERIENCE ARE YOU B 76672
2. GET FUZZY BLUE PRINT FOR DISASTER 68772
3. LIZZIE MCGUIRE V1 49694
4. YU GI OH V1 48308
5. BART SIMPSONS GUIDE TO LIFE 44944
6. ULTIMATE X MEN REV 41040
7. CHOBITS V1 38951
8. LEAGUE OF EXTRAORDINARY GENTLE 38714
9. CHOBITS V4 36910
10. HACK//LEGEND OF THE TWILIGHT V1 35889
11. FOXTROT YOUR MOMMA THINKS SQUARE ROOTS 35552
12. INU YASHA V1 2E 34777
13. THE BOONDOCKS RIGHT TO BE HOSTILE 32848
14. CHOBITS V5 32603
15. CHOBITS V2 32093
16. LOVE HINA V1 31290
17. RUROUNI KENSHIN V1 SHONEN JUMP 30627
18. ESSNTL CALVIN & HOBBES 30377
19. CHOBITS V6 29854
20. NARUTO V1 THE TESTS OF THE NINJA 29805
Ah the age of Chobits and Love Hina. It was so simple then. In 2003 the #20 book sold 29,805 issues; in 2013 it was 28,512. But in 2003 the total dollars in the top 750 was $66,729,053; in 2013 it was $96,062,709 even with the manga implosion and the death or Borders.
Remember these are still only rough comparison, given outlets, formats, etc. One number makes pie, the other breakfast juice. Still given all the crashes, publishing woes and the rise of digital, the fact that there has been significant growth in graphic novels can only be seen as a good thing.
Heidi MacDonald is the founder and editor in chief of The Beat. In the past, she worked for Disney, DC Comics, Fox and Publishers Weekly. She can be heard regularly on the More To Come Podcast. She likes coffee, cats and noble struggle.