Comic novels

0 Comments POSTED ON Nov 17 2006 AT 8:00 am BY Beat

It was a red letter day for The Beat when we finally got linked in Gawker in an item parsing Wil Moss’s report on the graphic novel symposium at the 92nd St. Y. Specifically…what to call those books of words and pictures.

La Perdida author Jessica Abel summed it up: “A graphic novel is a description, not a definition of an art form. We really need to repossess that word [comics] and make it something we can use.”

We totally support comic book nerds in their effort to take back this term, and we promise to use it every time we cover comic books, which is going to be . . . yeah, basically just this one time.


That’s fine. You just leave the comics to us. We know what we’re doing here. We are the deciders.

Actually, on one of the private mailing lists we’re on, people were discussing the same topic. We came up with an analogy we hadn’t thought of before, which, considering how much times we spend thinking about the comics, is highly surprising.

Why are comic books called comic books, anyway? Because somewhere in the mists of time they were named after “comic supplements” so called because they were…comic. I.E. funny. Like, for laughs. Thus the road to comic strips, and “the comics.”

So now we have “comics” which aren’t funny at all, and graphic “novels” which are actually based on true events. We’ve heard many people complain about the “novel” part of “graphic novel” for that very reason, including bibliographers, book shelvers and librarians…but it appears that “novel” will soon lose its original meaning in the neology, just as “comic” lost its.

As for us, comic book is downscale, graphic novel upscale. They will keep crossing over with ironic effect until some new genre buzzword comes along, like…”picto-rockets” or something.

Your Comments

No comments yet

  1. Liz says:

    I want a picto-rocket!!!

  2. MattR says:

    Picto-rocket does sound nifty.

    Much better than the term I came up with: “mix” for the floppies, “mix books” for the, well, not so floppies.


Share your view

Post a comment

Donate

Our Sponsors

Contributors

Heidi MacDonald, editor-in-chief

Assistant Editor: Kate Fitzsimons

Contributing Editors
Torsten Adair
Jen Vaughn

Technology Editor: Bruce Lidl
Entertainment Editor: Shannon O'Leary

Columnists:
Todd Alcott
Michel Fiffe
Marc-Oliver Frisch
Rich Johnson
Paul O'Brien
MK Reed

Illustrations:
Maggie Siegel-Berele

You like us! You really like us!

You may also like:

Let’s review!

November 2006
M T W T F S S
« Oct   Dec »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  

Upcoming Events

    No events to show

The Beat Twitter stream

CLASSIFIEDS

© 2006-2012 Heidi MacDonald - The Beat. Powered by Wordpress. All rights reserved. Logo by Comicraft.